default userpic

mt:comments lastn not working properly after 4.32 upgrade

Vote 0 Votes

I was running 4.21. Upgrade went smoothly. Except...

before: displayed (up to) the most recent 10 comments, most recent last.

after: displayed the *first* 10 comments. If I add "sort_order='descend' then the 10 most recent comments are displayed, most recent *first* - i.e. at the top, where it used to be at the bottom.

Any clues? I can change the template, if needed, but this took me be surprise and seems an unexpected change in behavior.

Thanks,

Leo

Reported on Movable Type 4.3

5 Replies

| Add a Reply
  • This ended up being confirmed by support as a problem. Sigh.

    My workaround - 'taint pretty, but it appears to work (for last '5' comments):

    <mt:SetVarBlock name="cComments"><$mt:EntryCommentCount$></mt:SetVarBlock>
    <mt:SetVarBlock name="offsetHack"><mt:Var name="cComments" op="-" value="5" /></mt:SetVarBlock>
    <mt:if name="offsetHack" lt="0">
      <mt:SetVar name="offsetHack" value="0" />
    </mt:if>
    <mt:comments lastn="5" offset="$offsetHack">
    ...

  • Just add sort_order="descend" to your "<mtComments> tag.

    Explanation here: http://bugs.movabletype.org/default.asp?102442 (bad design decision IMO)
    Supposedly fixed in MT5: http://bugs.movabletype.org/default.asp?100899

  • Adding sort_order="descend" did give me the X most recent comments, but listed with the most recent first. I wanted (and had) the X most recent, listed with the most recent *last*.

    (Thanks for the bug links.)

    Thanks,

    Leo

  • I'm having this same problem with MT 5.01. It isn't fixed yet.

  • I was having this problem with MT5. I fixed it with a teeny tiny hack to the Perl source. One line. I added...

    $args{'direction'} = 'descend';

    to /lib/MT/Template/Tags/Comment.pm at line 301. Now it really selects the most recent comments, and shows them in ascending order, the way I want. More details here.

Add a Reply

If you need to share template code, replace all the "<" signs with "&lt;" or use this utility.

Forum Groups

1773 6162

Last Topic: Excluding categories from blog by kholechek on Feb 9, 2012

86 302

Last Topic: website entries by masoud on Oct 26, 2011

1428 5076

Last Topic: Stupid Question? How to make a static homepage by Jeremy on Feb 3, 2012

694 2908

Last Topic: Blogspot to Movable Type by sdude on Feb 8, 2012

84 291

Last Topic: How to have some other characters in entry basename automatically written by Afshin Haghighatnia on Dec 22, 2011

173 737

Last Topic: About the MT version stated in HTML source by Alex E. Schneider on Feb 7, 2012

190 565

Last Topic: Analytics Reporting by michael webster on Feb 5, 2012

48 210

Last Topic: An idea and also a request by Afshin Haghighatnia on Jun 29, 2011

64 246

Last Topic: jQuery in MT 5.1 still at 1.4 - why? by perlmonkey on May 25, 2011

code.sixapart.com

137 478

Last Topic: Getting a thumbnail with xpath by Peter on Mar 13, 2011

222 716

Last Topic: Custom Field for Asset Not Appearing by android on Feb 9, 2012